To Nicola Stugeons Scottish Independence Plans, Caller Scottish Pokes Holes


“But we actually spend over 90b, so we have a shortfall of over 30b, which we actually get from the UK Government.

“And I look at it and think, how are we going to function as an independent country, furthermore if we have the SNP Government who if you look at Scotland we have had the ferry fiasco.

“And they reckon there’s going to be about £400m for these ferries, so what a waste of money or a lack of proper management.”

Elizabeth added: “Where the money which was meant to cost us 97b for two ferries, in I think 2017 and here we are they’re still not built.

Story Highlights

  • Elizabeth from East Lothian told Jeremy Vine on 5: “Well can I just say having listened to Pat, Scotland according to the last… Report, we create just over 60b of money for services.

  • “So that in actual fact we create quite a bit of debt on our own.

The new plans have also raised issues about a trade border between Scotland and England.

Nicola Sturgeon has been warned that a border would impact trade and the Scottish economy negatively.

First Minister Nicola Sturgeon has announced new plans for a second referendum despite previously holding one less than a decade ago. Mr Blackford defended the Scottish Independence vote today in Parliament.

Mr Blackford said: “Stronger together, has the Prime Minister seen the pound fall in the financial markets giving us a judgment on this, Prime Minister? “The Prime Minister can afford to live in his own little world, his own little Britain. But people have to live with the reality of a failing Westminster system.

“Our cost-of-living crisis worsened the UK more than any other G7 countries. And inflation rate doubled that of France – the second worse economic growth forecast in the G20 next to always-sanctioned Russia.” Unlike caller Elizabeth Mr Blackford claims to be a part of the Westminister system is holding Scotland back.

“Mr Speaker, Scotland wants to get on.”

Mr Blackford continued: “It’s not a vision for the future of Scotland. Our nation is big enough, rich enough, smart enough. Isn’t that the case, Prime Minister, that Scotland simply can’t afford to remain trapped in the failing Westminster system? Mr Blackford added: “And now on the thread of a trade war with our European friends triggered by a law-breaking Prime Minister.”